CBSSports.com draft analyst Josh Edwards released a list identifying the most questionable draft pick for each NFL team in the 2026 NFL Draft, which concluded on April 25, 2026 [1].
Five teams had their most questionable picks come in the first round. The Arizona Cardinals drew particular scrutiny for selecting running back Jeremiyah Love with the third overall pick. Critics noted the philosophical concerns of using such a high pick on a running back given the position’s shorter career span. Meanwhile, the Cardinals reportedly had greater needs at offensive line and quarterback, making the pick more controversial [1].
The Los Angeles Rams’ most questionable pick was quarterback Ty Simpson, chosen 13th overall. Concerns about Simpson included his limited starting experience—only one season—and a history of injuries. His relatively older age for a draft prospect added to the doubts surrounding the selection [1].
Minnesota Vikings’ most questionable selection was defensive lineman Caleb Banks at 18th overall. Though talented, Banks faces injury concerns, especially related to his size. The Vikings have also faced criticism for limited impact from recent drafts, magnifying doubts over this pick [1].
The 2026 NFL Draft ended nine days before May 4, 2026. Josh Edwards’ list highlights how several teams opted for prospects carrying notable risk or questions, particularly in the first round [1].
